telling vs. told

[nui]

Test No. incompl/inter-9 "Say/Tell", question 8

Now that would be ......... but my lips are sealed.

(a) told
(b) saying
(c) telling
(d) said

Test No. incompl/inter-9 "Say/Tell", answer 8

Now that would be telling but my lips are sealed.

Correct answer: (c) telling

Your answer was: incorrect
Now that would be told but my lips are sealed.
_________________________

Why use telling instead of told?

nui

[Alan]

Telling is used here because this is assumed to be happening or ( in this case) not happening but told would suggest that it has already happened.
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Present Simple

[ClaudiaJorge.]

[Alan]

Hi,

Basically tell is similar to relate: as in tell a story

Say is similar to speak as in: say words

Look at this sentence:

She said she would tell a story.

Alan
_________________
English as a Foreign Language
You can read my EFL story Progressive Forms

[filly]

[Haihao]

Hi,

I have two questions to ask of you because I am not clear enough with the sentence.

1. To me, 'Now that would be telling' suggests the subject is 'that'. I would feel more comfortable if the subject was a person and 'Now that would be told' would suggest a person.
2. Also to me, 'Now that would be told' is assumed to be happening or (in this case) not happening, too because of the word 'would'.

But I guess there should be something wrong with my understanding. Could you give me your explanations on these two points for me? Thank you very much.

haihao

[Yankee]

Hi Haihao

The word 'telling' is used as an adjective and I would understand the meaning in your sentence "Now that would be telling" to be one of these:

1. having force or effect; effective; striking: a telling blow.
2. revealing; indicative of much otherwise unnoticed: a telling analysis of motivation in business.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/telling

It's possible but much less likely (!!!) that this sentence could also be a conditional passive form of the verb 'tell' and refer to a possible future activity. This particular meaning would depend entirely on the context.

The verb 'tell' is usually followed by a person, but not always. Consider this sentence:
He told the truth.

Your second sentence ('Now that would be told') isn't particularly meaningful to me with no context. However, the construction is a passive form of the verb 'tell' and would have a sense of a completed action in the conditional future.

Amy
_________________
"Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power." ~ Abraham Lincoln

[Alan]

Hi Haihao,

I'm afraid I'm at a slight divergence with Amy over the expression: Now that would be telling. Admittedly telling as an adjective suggests effective and possibly evocative but in the test expression the word has a verbal function. The meaning is: Now if I told you what you wanted to know, that (the action of revealing the secret) would be me telling you what you want to know. In that sense it has a conditional function.

A
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Passive Voice

[Yankee]

Hi Alan

My reaction was to what Haihao asked about ("Now that would be telling." and "Now that would be told."). In other words, I thought Haihao wanted to know about two complete sentences rather than two partial sentences or the test sentence.

Hi Haihao

Sorry, if the examples you gave were not intended to be complete sentences, then please ignore my previous post.

Amy
_________________
"Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power." ~ Abraham Lincoln

[Lost_Soul]

Hi, Amy !

sorry for being thick-headed, but I can't get that sentence (i.e. Now that would be telling but my lips are sealed)
I know that "my lips are sealed" means "I will not utter anything" but I dont know what "that" pertains to? Is it some kind of sourse of information which would be telling me some story?

Could you help me out with this one, please

[Filcanlas]

Hi Alan

Thank you for your explanation that say is similar to speak and tell is to relate story. A simple explanation that will burn my heart to remember.

Have a great day
fil

[Gray]

[Schwartz]

I also don't understand "Now that would be telling but my lips are sealed." sentence.
hopefully someone help explain more.

[Kitosdad]

If someone were to ask you to confirm a rumour that you knew to be the truth, you could rightfully say, " Now, THAT would be telling."

That is the manner and circumstance in which this phrase is uttered.

Kitos.
_________________
Keep it simple ... Keep it interesting.

[Schwartz]

thx a lot.