Whose vs. who's

[Lily]

Test No. incompl/elem-9 "Relative Pronouns", question 8

Did you meet the lady ......... uncle works in the library?

(a) who
(b) whose
(c) who's

Test No. incompl/elem-9 "Relative Pronouns", answer 8

Did you meet the lady whose uncle works in the library?

Correct answer: (b) whose

Your answer was: incorrect
Did you meet the lady who's uncle works in the library?
_________________________

could you explain more, please
Thanks a lot

[Alan]

Who's is a contracted form of WHO IS.
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Have a Break!

[I_dunno]

who's can be a contraction of who is or it can show ownership. The who that owns something. "Who's shoe is this?"

[Alan]

Hi,

No, who's is only a contractionof who is. If you want to express possession, the relative pronoun is whose.
_________________
English as a Foreign Language
You can read my EFL story Adverbs

[saucyj]

"No, who's is only a contractionof who is" <-- not 100% true either.

who's is not ONLY a contraction of who is. it can also be who has as in "who's done this before?".

[bobmarleyisstupid]

Stop coming up with examples out of your butt. Just because you misuse the language frequently doesn't mean that you're right. Open your mind and learn something instead of stubbornly clinging to your wrongheaded ideas.

[hordover]

Who's and whose is just like It's and Its.
The apostrophe with both of these is JUST FOR THE CONTRACTION. The other form (whose, its) is for posession.
That's all

[Alan]

Hi Hordover,

Thanks for that - good point but remember the spelling: possession.

Alan
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Phrasal Verbs/take

[Fooz]

Hi Alan,

Can I say:

Did you meet the lady whose her uncle works in the library?

thanx

[Torsten]

Hi Fooz,

Welcome to english-test.net! You can say:

I met a lady whose uncle works at the library. Or:

I met a lady and she told me that her uncle works at the library.

Regards,
Torsten
_________________
Test Of English for International Communication
TOEIC Preparation & TOEIC Vocabulary

[Hanh]

Thanks Tosten. I understood why we used whose not who's in this sentence.