Did vs. have done

[rich7]

Test No. errors/inter-5 "Talk about it later", question 2

Who would know among all the people that matter that you done that?

(a) would
(b) among
(c) matter
(d) done

Test No. errors/inter-5 "Talk about it later", answer 2

Who would know among all the people that matter that you did that?

Correct entry: did
The error was: (d) done

You have found the error but your entry is incorrect.
Who would know among all the people that matter that you have done that?
_________________________

"did" agaisnt "have done" why?

[Alan]

You have an interesting question there. I think did is needed here because I have included the word that in the sentence to convey the idea of past. If it had been you have done, it would be you have done this.
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Your Choice

[rich7]

Do you mean the second that? if so, is this an indication of the past , why?

thanks again...
_________________
I should have been born in the USA.
I've got this thing about America.

[Torsten]

Actually, it's the third that in that sentence and it means that something had been done in the past. Let's assume the following conversation is going on:

A: Do you recognize what I have done for mankind?

B: Well, to be honest I can't quite follow you.

A: I'm sure you remember that it was me who invented a winter hat with electrical heating.

B: Who would know among all the people that matter that you did that? (inventing that winter hat.)
_________________
Test Of English for International Communication
TOEIC Preparation & TOEIC Vocabulary