"one year" vs. "a year"

Camie · Sun Dec 31, 2006 13:29 pm *"one year" vs. "a year"*

Hello!
I'm new here and I have a question. Should we use the indefinite article or the numeral in these examples:

I will live there a year.
or
I will live there one year.

Thank you!

Alan · Sun Dec 31, 2006 13:42 pm *"one year" vs. "a year"*

Hi and welcome to the site,

I think you should add 'for' to both sentences. The only difference is in the suggestion that 'a' is more general than the use of 'one' If you say: I will live there for one year, you are being very precise about the duration of your stay but of course the meaning is the same for both because it is still 12 months.

Alan
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story A day in the life of a flat hunter

Camie · Sun Dec 31, 2006 13:47 pm *"one year" vs. "a year"*

Thank you for your answer!

In fact while writing the sentences I wasn't sure whether to use "for" or not. Smile

Tom · Sun Dec 31, 2006 16:17 pm *"one year" vs. "a year"*

Thanks, Alan. Very Happy

Am I allowed to shed some of my light on the sentences? Shocked

Please see if I am right!

Hi Camie

When "one" is understood, we use "a". For example:

1- I want a cup of tea. ("one" is understood)

2- The bus fell into a ravine but only "one" passenger was killed. (Here we cannot use "a" because we have to be precise, as Alan said in his explanation.

Tom

Alan · Sun Dec 31, 2006 16:42 pm *"one year" vs. "a year"*

Hi Tom,

Spot on!

A
_________________
English as a Foreign Language
You can read my EFL story Progressive Forms

	ESL Forums \| English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms	All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Page 1 of 1