#2 (permalink) Sun Jan 28, 2007 12:55 pm Participle: Why there are no 'is' after 1. 'it' and 2. 'as'? |
|
|
What you're seeing in your first sentence is called a "small clause". In syntax, this term is used to describe a type of clause that has a noun phrase (NP) as a subject, and then any other type of phrase, such as a verb phrase (VP), a prepositional phrase (PP), an adjective phrase (AP), etc., as a complement. It has no position for an auxiliary verb, or for the verb to be (am, is, are, etc.), so there is no verb tense, and often no verb.
Examples:
Full sentence: John is president of the club. As a small clause: They elected John president of the club. They elected NP[John] NP[president of the club]
Full sentence: The test is unnecessary. As a small clause: They consider the test unnecessary. They elected NP[the test] AP[unnecessary]
It is necessary to adopt such a test. Many people consider NP[it] AP[necessary to adopt such a test].
In your sentence number 2, the word being is a gerund taking the place of the word is after the preposition as. You have the idiom to regard [noun] as [noun phrase or adjective phrase]:
Some people regard him as NP[the best person for the job].
Some regard the test as NP[being unnecessary]. The noun in this sentence is the gerund "being".
Notice that you can say the same thing using just the adjective "unnecessary":
Some regard the test as AP[unnecessary]. |
|
Jamie (K) I'm a Communicator ;-)
Joined: 24 Feb 2006 Posts: 6552 Location: Detroit, Michigan, USA
|