Google
English-Test.net
Find penpals and make new friends today!
 
to endanger; to imperil; to dare; to venture
debut
slope
install
hazard
TOEIC exam test: Word games online: Free Verb Game Answer
 
Username
Password
 Remember me? 
Search   FAQ   Memberlist   Profile   Private messages   Register   Log in 

all tenses mixed, in one exercise...



 
ESL/EFL Worksheets and Handouts for Students Printable, photocopiable, clearly structured
Designed for teachers and individual learners
For use in a classroom, at home, on your PC
ESL Forum | English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms
Difference between "job" and "work" | Incorrect sentences: The man speaking to Vickey yesterday...
Message Author
all tenses mixed, in one exercise... Tue Apr 24, 2007 19:21 pm  all tenses mixed, in one exercise...
 

Hello there!

I've just completed an exercise from a book called "A Proficiency Course In English" (Bywater) concerning tenses, and I have some questions about it. Could you give me your explanations? (since the key doesn't say anything apart from giving the answer only)

1. I wonder who is making / was making that dreadful row. - are both versions possible? the second one seems a bit odd, especially out of context... to me...

2. After he had eaten an enormous dinner, he fell asleep and was dreaming peacefully when a lump of coal fell on to the heart and woke him up. - Could you please tell me, why there is past perfect used? Is it necessary here? Could I use simple past?

3. I had been living / lived in that flat for several years before I decided / had decided to look round for something more central. - Wchich version is correct? Could I simply use the simple past tense here? We have words like "before" don't we? So is present perfect necessary (especially in the second part) ?

4. I shall / will have finished the book in about twenty minutes' time; can;t you wait until then? - The key gives "shall" and I don't know whether "will" and "shall" differ in any way... do they? Besides, I wanna know whether I could simply say "I will finish the book in about 20 minutes..." and if not, why???

5. The Incas were beaten in battle by the Spanish conquistadores and, after being held / were held / they had been held in captivity for some time, their Emperor was murdered. - The key says "had been held" and I have no idea why... couldn't I simply say "were held" ? or "being held" ? why not?

6. Have you seen my glasses? - Can I say "Did you see my glasses" ? why/why not?

7. When I arrived on the field yesterday, preparations were / had been in the full swing for the Fair which opens today... - again, sp vs p. perf. - The key says "were" and I would say "had been" ... is it wrong to use the past perfect here? what would it take to use it? adding a word like "already" maybe?

8. I met your sister yesterday and I think / thought she was looking very well / she looks very well. - Can I use simple present? If I mean that she looks fine, like... kind of... generally! And does "thought" imply that I thought that in the past and I don't think that anymore? or does it mean more like "generally" ? Could I use "I think..." here? why not?

9. Tolstoy tried / had been trying / had tried to educate his serfs but after he had been working / working / having been working at it for 20 years he got discouraged and gave it up. - Here, I'm completely confused... The key says "tried" and "had been working" ... dunno why... and why the rest is wrong...

All the best to you guys! I'm counting on you Wink Thanks in advance!

PS. Is that true that if a Brit guy comes to the USA and uses a/the word "fortnight" he may not be understood?
Forum_Mail
New Member


Joined: 25 Mar 2007
Posts: 5

all tenses mixed, in one exercise... Wed Apr 25, 2007 7:51 am  all tenses mixed, in one exercise...
 

You have a lot of questions...I haven't much time now so I'll come back with more answers later Smile.
#1 I think should be "was making" unless the act is happening right now, which is unlikely. You usually wonder about what had happened in the past.
#2 "had eaten" is more correct since the past perfect tense is used to describe something that happened before another event (also in the past). He had fallen asleep before he fell asleep. You seem to have problems with this concept Smile. If you use nothing but past tense then it may get confusing at times. Use past perfect to differentiate sequence of events.
#3 In my opinion, it should be past perfect then past.
Diverhank
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 25 Apr 2007
Posts: 331
Location: California, USA

Are you a native speaker of English? Then you should read this!English grammar exercises — improve your English knowledge and vocabulary skillsHow many different ways with words do you know? Subscribe to free email English courseDo you know how to use the relative pronoun?
all tenses mixed, in one exercise... Wed Apr 25, 2007 21:52 pm  all tenses mixed, in one exercise...
 

To continue on,
#4...I'm not sure if there's any difference between shall and will in this case...shall sounds more like King's English, maybe. In my opinion, you can use "I will finish..." but grammatically, the key is right because technically you could not have known for certain that you will finish it in 20 minutes...by using "shall have finished", it gives the possibility that you could be wrong...however, I think many modern writers are moving away from heavy handed sentences like "shall have finished". I won't hesitate to use "I will finish", but then I'm not a teacher of English Smile.

#5...again past perfect is used to describe something that happened before another past event (had been held before king was murdered)

#6...When you say "did you see my glasses", it begs the question of when? and how many times? By using "have you seen...", it covers all events.
#7...Both events (arrived and in full swing) happened at the same time. "had been" would be OK like you said with a "already"
Diverhank
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 25 Apr 2007
Posts: 331
Location: California, USA

all tenses mixed, in one exercise... Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 am  all tenses mixed, in one exercise...
 

.
My opinions:

1. I wonder who is making / was making that dreadful row. - 'is' for the current event, 'was' for the past event; both are possible here.

2. After he had eaten an enormous dinner, he fell asleep and was dreaming peacefully when a lump of coal fell on to the heart and woke him up. - Past perfect is unnecessary where the sequence of events is evident; it is made clear here by the word 'after', so simple past is fine.

3. I had been living / lived in that flat for several years before I decided / had decided to look round for something more central. - As above. Simple past is perfectly adequate unless surrounding context causes confusion about event sequence.

4. I shall / will have finished the book in about twenty minutes' time; can;t you wait until then? - In AmE, 'shall' and 'will' are interchangeable here, but 'shall' is seldom used; it is considered overly formal. You can say 'I will finish' if you like; the tense used here merely throws the speaker and listener's perspective into the future event to follow.

5. The Incas were beaten in battle by the Spanish conquistadores and, after being held / were held / they had been held in captivity for some time, their Emperor was murdered. - 'Were held' does not fit the grammar of the sentence as you have presented it. 'Being held' would have an ambiguous subject.

6. Have you seen my glasses? - Can I say "Did you see my glasses" ? why/why not? -- Both fine and common as used here. The simple past is more usual in AmE.

7. When I arrived on the field yesterday, preparations were / had been in the full swing for the Fair which opens today... - Past perfect is wrong here; preparations were still going on at the time of arrival.

8. I met your sister yesterday and I think / thought she was looking very well / she looks very well. - Yes, you can use present if the conditions still obtain.

9. Tolstoy tried / had been trying / had tried to educate his serfs but after he had been working / working / having been working at it for 20 years he got discouraged and gave it up. - As before: with 'after', the sequence of events is clear and simple past could have been used. Many writers use past perfect just to stress the temporal distance between the events.

PS. Is that true that if a Brit guy comes to the USA and uses a/the word "fortnight" he may not be understood? -- I understand and am AmE. As a child, I attended a school club in Illinois held once in two weeks and called 'Fortnightly'.
.
_________________
Canadian-American native speaker
who teaches English for a living at Mister Micawber's
ESL cafe: Interview with Mister Micawber
Mister Micawber
Language Coach
Mister Micawber

Joined: 17 Jul 2005
Posts: 4646
Location: Yokohama, Japan

Display posts from previous:   
Difference between "job" and "work" | Incorrect sentences: The man speaking to Vickey yesterday...
ESL Forum | English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms all tenses mixed, in one exercise... All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Page 1 of 1
Latest topics on English Forums
the usage of the verb wishLet's start vs Let's get startedCould anybody please help shed some light on this?a couple of english idiomsmeaning of "defending champions"sole use by the following people or of the following people?What do 'dumbed down' and 'high brow' mean here?What does 'which' here mean?A few questions about English grammarThe use of definite article "the" before proper nounsExpression: to get married inUnit vs Modulestay away vs keep away; "pass away" vs "fade away"Difference between "Not Given" and "Not been given"?Did you see the tabloid in today's paper? The Prime Minister has resigned!What is the name for this phenomenon?How do you say hello with somebody you see first time of every day?Please give my some advice about pronunciation...all tenses mixed, in one exercise...

Discover English-test.net
In nature vs. in the natureOn time vs. in timeExpression: God forbid"do one's duty on smb" or "do one's duty to smb"?Usage of past perfectGRE test: Vocabulary Words: Examples of Nouns AdjectivesGRE test: Word games: Free Online Nouns Adjectives GameDefine scapegoat, limbo, canker, optometrist, jingoism, dialecticVocabulary list: Verbs nouns adjectivesFree ESL Quiz Online: Ways of showing pleasureCareers in business management: Employee Performance AppraisalRun for Home audiobook download

 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Subscribe to FREE email English course
First name E-mail