Google
English-Test.net
Find penpals and make new friends today!
 
to apply force or weight; to push; to stress
support
pressure
harvest
registering
TOEIC vocab test: Free word games: Online Verb Noun Adjective Game Answer
 
Username
Password
 Remember me? 
Search   FAQ   Memberlist   Profile   Private messages   Register   Log in 

She said if I were vs. had been



 
ESL/EFL Worksheets and Handouts for Students Printable, photocopiable, clearly structured
Designed for teachers and individual learners
For use in a classroom, at home, on your PC
ESL Forums | English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms
obscure avenue | asked to/of him
Message Author
She said if I were vs. had been Fri Aug 10, 2007 17:55 pm  She said if I were vs. had been
 

1. I know this one.

If I were you (now), I would be happy (now).

2. I don't get this one. Which one is correct?

She said if I had been you, I would have been happy.
She said if I were you, I would be happy.
edison_chen_e_c
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 206

She said if I were/had been~ Fri Aug 10, 2007 18:24 pm  She said if I were/had been~
 

edison_chen_e_c wrote:
1.I know this one.
If I were you (now), I would be happy (now).

2.I don't get this one. Which one is correct?
She said if I had been you, I would have been happy.
She said if I were you, I would be happy.

"She said if I were you I would be happy." is correct. Smile
Harry Smiith
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 15 Jul 2007
Posts: 112
Location: Moscow, Russia

English grammar exercises — improve your English knowledge and vocabulary skillsHow many different ways with words do you know? Subscribe to free email English courseWhat do you know about the progressive forms?Are you a native speaker of English? Then you should read this!
She said if I were/had been~ Sun Aug 12, 2007 13:03 pm  She said if I were/had been~
 

Harry Smiith wrote:
edison_chen_e_c wrote:
1.I know this one.
If I were you (now), I would be happy (now).

2.I don't get this one. Which one is correct?
She said if I had been you, I would have been happy.
She said if I were you, I would be happy.

"She said if I were you I would be happy." is correct. Smile

She said if I had been you, I would have been happy.
Is it wrong? Shouldn't I use past perfective?
edison_chen_e_c
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 206

She said if I were/had been~ Sun Aug 12, 2007 15:53 pm  She said if I were/had been~
 

for me both are wrong

She said that if she had been me, she would have been happy.
She said: "if I were you, I would be happy".
_________________
Alex

How much upchuck would a woodchuck upchuck if a woodchuck could upchuck ?

(a guy from Russia)
lost_soul
I'm a Communicator ;-)


Joined: 15 Sep 2006
Posts: 1812
Location: South Park, Colorado, USA

She said if I were/had been~ Sun Aug 12, 2007 17:31 pm  She said if I were/had been~
 

lost_soul wrote:
for me both are wrong

She said that if she had been me, she would have been happy.
She said: "if I were you, I would be happy".

Could you give your reason?
Harry Smiith
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 15 Jul 2007
Posts: 112
Location: Moscow, Russia

She said if I were/had been~ Mon Aug 13, 2007 6:46 am  She said if I were/had been~
 

Harry Smiith wrote:
lost_soul wrote:
for me both are wrong

She said that if she had been me, she would have been happy.
She said: "if I were you, I would be happy".

Could you give your reason?

If it becomes this:
Mary said if Pitt were Dave, Pitt would be happy.
Mary said if Pitt had been Dave, Pitt would have been happy.
edison_chen_e_c
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 206

She said if I were/had been~ Mon Aug 13, 2007 13:15 pm  She said if I were/had been~
 

.
As I see it, the way these sentences are changed to reported speech (form of the verbs) depends on the broader context. It is also likely that the "If I were you" part of the direct quote would simply be omitted in the reported speech.

LS's point about changing 'I' to 'she' is valid. Her direct speech was "If I were you". If "you" later reports to a third person what she said, then it would change to She said that if she were me, she would be happy or She said that if she had been me, she would have been happy.

If the situation (context) here is still current or valid at the time the original statement is reported, the verb forms would be best unchanged:

A to B (A's direct quote on Tuesday): "If I were you, I would be happy about having to work overtime every day this week."

B to C, reported speech (Wednesday): She said that (if she were me,) she would be happy about having to work overtime every day this week.

-OR-

B to C, reported speech (a week later): She said that (if she had been me,) she would have been happy about having to work overtime every day last week.
.

_________________
Amy
.
ESL teacher, translator, and a native speaker of American English
Yankee
I'm a Communicator ;-)


Joined: 16 Apr 2006
Posts: 7866
Location: USA

She said if I were/had been~ Tue Aug 14, 2007 9:02 am  She said if I were/had been~
 

Yankee wrote:
.
As I see it, the way these sentences are changed to reported speech (form of the verbs) depends on the broader context. It is also likely that the "If I were you" part of the direct quote would simply be omitted in the reported speech.

LS's point about changing 'I' to 'she' is valid. Her direct speech was "If I were you". If "you" later reports to a third person what she said, then it would change to She said that if she were me, she would be happy or She said that if she had been me, she would have been happy.

If the situation (context) here is still current or valid at the time the original statement is reported, the verb forms would be best unchanged:

A to B (A's direct quote on Tuesday): "If I were you, I would be happy about having to work overtime every day this week."

B to C, reported speech (Wednesday): She said that (if she were me,) she would be happy about having to work overtime every day this week.

-OR-

B to C, reported speech (a week later): She said that (if she had been me,) she would have been happy about having to work overtime every day last week.
.

Well, I'm still a little confused.

1.All are the same meaning?
Last week Mary said "If I were Pitt, I would study hard."
=Last week Mary said that if she had been Pitt, she would have studied hard.
=Last week Mary said that if she were Pitt, she would study hard.

2.Which is better?

It is time you should go to bed.
It is time you should have gone to bed.

It was time you should go to bed.
It was time you should have gone to bed.

If there's a main clause in past tense, when to use 'It was time you should go to bed.', when to use 'It was time you should have gone to bed.'

Thanks in advance.
edison_chen_e_c
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 206

She said if I were/had been~ Tue Aug 14, 2007 10:01 am  She said if I were/had been~
 

Hi edison_chen_e_c,

You might care to look at some material I've written for the site on Indirect/Reported Speech:http://www.english-test.net/lessons/6/index.html

It's also worth noting that changing from direct to indirect can sometimes result in a bit of a mouthful as: If he had been me, he would have done it differently and often we would leave it as: If he were me, he would do it differently keeping as it were the 'actualty' of the words fresh in the mind although of course the first construction is the 100% correct one.

On the other matter we would say: It's time you went to bed, where 'went' is the subjunctive or 'unreal past'.

Again you may care to look at this on the subjunctive:http://www.english-test.net/lessons/15/index.html

Hope these notes help.

Alan
_________________
English as a Second Language
You can read my ESL story Relative Pronoun
Alan
Co-founder
Alan Townend

Joined: 27 Sep 2003
Posts: 7392
Location: UK

She said if I were/had been~ Wed Aug 15, 2007 9:06 am  She said if I were/had been~
 

Alan wrote:
Hi edison_chen_e_c,

You might care to look at some material I've written for the site on Indirect/Reported Speech:http://www.english-test.net/lessons/6/index.html

It's also worth noting that changing from direct to indirect can sometimes result in a bit of a mouthful as: If he had been me, he would have done it differently and often we would leave it as: If he were me, he would do it differently keeping as it were the 'actualty' of the words fresh in the mind although of course the first construction is the 100% correct one.

On the other matter we would say: It's time you went to bed, where 'went' is the subjunctive or 'unreal past'.

Again you may care to look at this on the subjunctive:http://www.english-test.net/lessons/15/index.html

Hope these notes help.

Alan

Thanks, Mr. Alan, it's helpful.
edison_chen_e_c
I'm here quite often ;-)


Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 206

Display posts from previous:   
obscure avenue | asked to/of him
ESL Forums | English Vocabulary, Grammar and Idioms She said if I were vs. had been All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Page 1 of 1
Latest topics on ESL EFL Forums
Relative cleuses "that" or "about which"meaning of the phrase 'withering intelligence'Is journalist uncountable?Meaning of "wandering the streets, lost"Use of "better off""caring for" vs "caring"What does "bright in easy ways" mean?"Introduction to" vs "Introducton of"biography, thorough and easily observedmeaning of homeliness and fleshy skin"I don't remember that I've visited..."number/numbers"The shoe is on the other foot now, IS IT?"better off (I will be better off after I get a good job)Use of 'went off' (I already went off when she came in my house)"which one of" v.s. "who of"Is there anything who comes from overseas should be made aware of?IELTS - I want to develop my reading and writing skillsShe said if I were vs. had been

Discover English-test.net
Condition with 'should'Novel: The woman in whiteWho is Daniela (Moderator)?Hi everybody! I am very happy to join this forum.GMAT practice test: Vocabulary Websites: Examples of Verbs AdjectivesGMAT practice test: Online word games: Free Verbs Adjectives GameMeaning of objurgate, foray, preponderate, seethe, covetousAmerican vocabulary: Noun adjective verb adverbPhrase meaning origin saying idioms: ComputersEnglish grammar quiz: English Slang Idioms (248)

 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Subscribe to FREE email English course written by Alan Townend
First name E-mail