|
|
#2 (permalink) Sat Aug 16, 2008 10:08 am Can any native speaker of British English help me, please? |
|
|
Hi Sitifan,
This isn't really to do with the variety of English you speak or write but one of interpretation. If you use the plural verb as in: my class are/the government are, you are thinking of the individuals that make up the class/government. If you use the singular verb as in: my class is/the government is, you are thinking of them/it as one entity.
Alan _________________ English as a Second Language You can read my ESL story Present Simple |
|
Alan Co-founder

Joined: 27 Sep 2003 Posts: 13896 Location: UK
|
|
#3 (permalink) Sat Aug 16, 2008 13:31 pm My class is going to visit the museum. vs My class are going to visit the museum. |
|
|
An American says: '"My class are going to visit the museum," would sound wrong to most speakers of AmE, I believe.' _________________ Thank you very much for your reply. |
|
Sitifan I'm here quite often ;-)
Joined: 12 Mar 2008 Posts: 282 Location: Taiwan
|
 |
#4 (permalink) Sat Aug 16, 2008 13:34 pm My class is going to visit the museum. vs My class are going to visit the museum. |
|
|
The following is quoted from a native speaker of British English: ----------------------------------------------------------------- It would also sound wrong to most speakers of BrE. It's true that BrE often treats a collective noun as plural, but it can be also treated as singular, depending on context. The choice between singular and plural is often used to make a subtle distinction. "The government is ..." means "The government, considered as a single entity, is ...". "The government are ..." refers to the group of people who make up the government. Now, there are some situations where that distinction can't be made. "The team is expected to win tomorrow" is a meaningful statement. It refers to the team as an entity in its own right. The alternative, "the team are expected to win tomorrow", seems to suggest that most members of the team will win but perhaps some will not. That makes no sense, therefore I wouldn't say it. Your example, "My class are going to visit the museum", makes sense only if you think of the class in terms of the individuals in the class. It could, just possibly, refer to a situation where each member of the class is going to visit the museum, as an individual, and probably not at the same time as other class members. That's such an unlikely interpretation that I'd be forced to say that the "are" in that example is just plain wrong. _________________ Thank you very much for your reply. |
|
Sitifan I'm here quite often ;-)
Joined: 12 Mar 2008 Posts: 282 Location: Taiwan
|
 |
|
| on/in (the/a) bed | Could not have taken it v/s cannot have taken it? |