#1 (permalink) Sun Sep 06, 2009 5:58 am when can we omit the subject in a sentence? |
|
|
My question is: when can we omit the subject in a sentence? Some notes:
1)I asked this question on a forum "Please come to visit the New International Hotel in the convenient city center location. The hotel is just minutes away from great shopping. A bank and a famous cafe are next to the hotel. Across the street is a popular bakery. You can also visit beaches by bus, about 15 minutes away. By subway, you can go to interesting shops and gourmet restaurants. You can even visit a discothéque or pub. Taxi service is available 24 hours. Is the sentence "Across the street is a popular bakery" correct or should it be "Across the street there is a popular bakery"?What if we say "Next door is a bakery", is that correct?"
and I got the replies: "Both are correct. A popular bakery IS across the street. Statement of fact. It's the same format as the previous sentence about the bank and cafe.
There is a popular ... tells you that if you are looking for a bakery then there is one across the street.
Additional Q.. Yes. Well No actually. The bakery is across the street, not next door. Next door are a bank and a cafe." (za) Either is correct. The more common way is to omit the 'there'.(William W)
2) I am aware some special sentences don't need a subject or predicate, for example exclamation or dialogue sentences. I am not asking about these- I ask about common "not so peculiar" sentences, as the ones I mentioned above. Is "across the street" a subject, it doesn't look like that to me.
3)"Be careful not to omit "it" from an expletive(also called a subject filler)
NO: is a lovely day.
YES: It is a lovely day "(Handbook for writers, Simon and Schuster)
4) Note that saying "Is a lovely day" is acceptable in languages like Spanish or Romanian. |
|
Bogdanno2 I'm new here and I like it ;-)
Joined: 03 Jul 2009 Posts: 16
|