With my father

[Haihao]

Hi,

I ran into these sentences as follows:

1. With my father he is patient.
2. *With my father my mother is patient.

The book says #2 is incorrect. Could you tell me why? I really have no idea. And

3. With my father he takes a walk after breakfast.
4. *With my father he took a walk this morning.

Why #4 is incorrect?

Thank you!

[Alan]

Hi Haihao,

Your sentence:

[Haihao]

Hi Alan,

Thank you so much as always.

Haihao