the usage of "work"

[Takashiro]

I made 2 mistakes in a recent English Exercise. To my disappointment, the dictionary can't give me a detailed explaination.

One of the mistakes I made:
26. I don't think the scene with the horses really ( ).
A. OK B. proper C. works D. fits

I thought "work" could only be used like "function" or "run", apart from its original meaning.
eg. The machine doesn't work.
I've tried several spells myself, but they all work for me. ----------from Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone

Then, I chose D, and got a big cross. I wonder why Option A and D aren't acceptable.

[Haihao]

I would think "fit" should be, if used here, with "in"; and "I don't think the scene with the horses really OK" sounds odd because the direct object is too long, I guess.

[Beeesneees]

'fit' doesn't need 'in'.

"I don't think the scene with the horses really fits." makes sense without it, but [b]only[./b] if discussing a film where the scene is at odds to the rest of the film.

Such a scenario is not described here, so the correct answer, "I don't think the scene with the horses really works." (The scene is not just mismatched with the rest of the film - even taken alone it's a weak scene) is the best answer out of the options given. As with all multiple choice questions, you have to ensure you have chosen the best possible option.
_________________
Cheers m' dears!

[Haihao]

Is it possible that "I don't think the scene with the horses really works." = "I don't think the scene really works with the horses."?

[Beeesneees]

No. It means that the scene with the horses hasn't turned out well.
_________________
Cheers m' dears!

[Haihao]

How about:

A: I want those horses to be added to the scene.
B: I don't think the scene with the horses really works.

[Beeesneees]

I'm not sure what you are asking about:

A. is grammatically correct, but doesn't mean the same as the original post.

B. is the correct answer to the original post.
_________________
Cheers m' dears!

[Haihao]

I meant to show a dialogue between A and B, BN.

A (Johnson): I want those horses to be added to the scene.
B (John): I don't think the scene with the horses really works.

And I am afraid that you have excluded the possibility that the event (the scene in combination with the horses) has not yet taken place. Please take a look at the original one more time: I don't think the scene with the horses really works. Cf.:

[Beeesneees]

Ah, thank you. Now I understand about the dialogue. You are also correct that it could be 'the scene with the horses will not turn out well', though this would be less likely than a past tense meaning. In any event, whether it is future or past, the best fit word would still be 'works' not 'fits', wouldn't it?
_________________
Cheers m' dears!

[Haihao]

I agree 100%, BN, and thank you.

[Takashiro]

Having read your replies for several times, I've fully understood. Thanks, BN and Haihao-san.

[Haihao]

You are very welcome, Mr/Mrs/Miss High Castle. :-)

[Beeesneees]

Glad you agree with us, Maria.
_________________
Cheers m' dears!

[Takashiro]

[Haihao]

Thank you, Mr. Wisdom. :-)