#2 (permalink) Sat Jul 17, 2010 13:22 pm Question about questions |
|
|
Only the second is a question, although all three intend to prompt a response. As 1 and 3 are both indicative, they should be punctuated accordingly.
I cannot conceive of a situation where the second isn't a question. I don't think "passiveness" at all applies.
Rhetorical questions, those that seek no response and are often used for effect, can be punctuated with periods.
Should we place our children in the hands of arrant incompetents? Should we place our children in the hands of arrant incompetents.
Often they are exaggerated questions that all but compel agreement with the speaker. (And, for that very reason, they are just as often ineffective.)
Sometimes questions are worded like statements in dialogue, especially to express surprise or doubt.
You've never lied before, Alex? Wow, you bought me a car?
The first sentence suggests Alex has claimed never to have lied before.
I've pointed this out before, but grammar aside, something apart from an interrogative sentence can be a question. Someone asked whether Shakespeare misused "question" when he presented the famous "to be or not to be" dilemma. It can be a choice between difficult options or something warranting relatively serious consideration.
The question before us is whether to seek war today to ensure peace tomorrow. The question we eternally consider is whether to side with order or liberty where they conflict. |
|
Mordant Language Coach
Joined: 12 May 2010 Posts: 1964 Location: United States
|