|
|
#2 (permalink) Sun Apr 23, 2006 3:38 am Tense: Someone called while I took my shower... |
|
|
All of them are grammatical, in my judgment.
Sentence a sounds to me as if someone was making phone calls at the same time the other person was taking his shower.
Sentence b sounds to me as if someone's shower was interrupted by a phone call, or as if he didn't didn't hear the phone because it rang while he was in the shower.
Sentences c and d can mean exactly the same thing, which is that someone was waiting outside while someone else was talking about something. However, c can mean that this was something that happened regularly, and d probably wouldn't mean that, although it could.
I don't have the sense that c means that he waited outside from the beginning of the talk till the end. It just means that it was typical for him to wait outside while we talked. |
|
Jamie (K) I'm a Communicator ;-)
Joined: 24 Feb 2006 Posts: 6552 Location: Detroit, Michigan, USA
|
|
#3 (permalink) Sun Apr 23, 2006 8:44 am Called |
|
|
Hi azz,
You asked whether the following uses of Past Simple and Continuous change the meaning in:
| Quote: |
a. Someone called while I took my shower. b. Someone called while I was taking my shower.
c. He waited outside while we talked about it. d. He waited outside while we were talking about it. |
Grammatically they may be sound but the meaning is confusing to me in (a). (b) is crystal clear in the sense that in the middle of the shower someone called. There could also be some confusion about what you mean by called - is it phoned or visited? (c) and (d) suggest that the waiting and the talking were contemporaneous, which is acceptable. (d) by using the Past Continuous merely highlights the activity of talking going on, slightly different from the meaning in (c) but the difference is not really material. To me the odd one out is (a) in terms of meaning/sense because it is difficult to imagine the showering and the calling taking place at the same time and throughout the duration of both.
Just some thoughts.
Alan _________________ English as a Second Language You can read my ESL story Present Simple |
|
Alan Co-founder

Joined: 27 Sep 2003 Posts: 13887 Location: UK
|
 |
|
| If I had known the recipe I would have baked or baken a cake | Meaning of "this shit is bananas" |