#2 (permalink) Sun Jan 08, 2012 21:52 pm Re: looking forward to hearing your opinion about this independent writing sample |
|
|
Hi, You have written a pretty good essay. Your introduction should be reorganized. I am not a TOEFL grader, but in my opinion based on these criteria: http://www.ets.org/toefl/pbt/scores/writing_score_guide/ I would give this essay a 4.5/6. Just by adding the thesis statement at the right place it would be at least a 5.
| Mochad wrote: |
Question: Some items (such as clothes or furniture) can be made by hand or by machine. Which do you prefer — items made by hand or items made by machine? Use reasons and specific examples to explain your choice.
Hand made items are preferable on[to] those produced by machines. Buying a hand crafted product will end up boosting the economy. In addition, these items include added value and worth to be purchased{this phrase is awkward} unlike similar products done[made] by robots. Added value includes priceless human power, their precious time and valuable efforts. {put your thesis statement that directly answers the prompt as the last sentence of your introduction}
[A] Hand craft business in any industry is usually a small one, meaning that it employ[s ] less than twenty worker[s ]. It is also associated with a limited amount of capital. On the other hand, there exists the multi-million [dollar] factories. Despite their overwhelming capital, such businesses hire much less labors than their rivals from the hand made{one word} businesses do. This is becuase {sp} they are much [more] dependent on robots and machines. The aforementioned fact implements that buying a hand crafted item will flourish this business thus urging it to expend, therefore adding additional jobs to the economy. {awkward - try "These facts imply that buying a hand-crafted item will allow the small businesses to flourish and expand, while adding additional jobs to the economy.} Lower unemployment rates ensues an [will ensue, as well as] economical growth.
Moreover, hand made items are known as "value added items". Human power is one of the most important factors that provides an added value to a hand craft. In the end, humans are more creative than machines, {new sentence} consequently, a craftsman[-produced] product is more creative than that of a machine. Further, a craftsman requires additional time and much more effort to exert on an item to finish it than those[that] needed by a machine. Though some would believe that it[this] is a negative factor, but {can't have "Though" and this "but" in the same sentence} by the means of "added value" it is completely the opposite, implying that hand crafted items are more precious.
To put [it] in a nutshell, the awareness about the importance of hand made{one word} items should be spread, additionally, such products should be supported. Such support will benefit no one else than the supporter himself. {will benefit not only the maker of hand-crafts, but also the purchaser himself.}
TOEFL listening discussions: What is the main weakness of the student's essay? |
|
|
Luschen I'm a Communicator ;-)

Joined: 08 Apr 2011 Posts: 2135 Location: Nashville TN, USA
|